“The True Blasphemy”: Slavoj Žižek on Pussy Riot

The True Blasphemy

Pussy Riot members accused of blasphemy and hatred of religion? The answer is easy: the true blasphemy is the state accusation itself, formulating as a crime of religious hatred something which was clearly a political act of protest against the ruling clique. Recall Brecht’s old quip from his Beggars’ Opera: “What is the robbing of a bank compared to the founding of a new bank?” In 2008, Wall Street gave us the new version: what is the stealing of a couple of thousand of dollars, for which one goes to prison, compared to financial speculations that deprive tens of millions of their homes and savings, and are then rewarded by state help of sublime grandeur? Now, we got another version from Russia, from the power of the state: What is a modest Pussy Riot obscene provocation in a church compared to the accusation against Pussy Riot, this gigantic obscene provocation of the state apparatus which mocks any notion of decent law and order?

Was the act of Pussy Riot cynical? There are two kinds of cynicism: the bitter cynicism of the oppressed which unmasks the hypocrisy of those in power, and the cynicism of the oppressors themselves who openly violate their own proclaimed principles. The cynicism of Pussy Riot is of the first kind, while the cynicism of those in power — why not call their authoritarian brutality a Prick Riot — is of the much more ominous second kind.

Back in 1905, Leon Trotsky characterized tsarist Russia as “a vicious combination of the Asian knout and the European stock market.” Does this designation not hold more and more also for the Russia of today? Does it not announce the rise of the new phase of capitalism, capitalism with Asian values (which, of course, has nothing to do with Asia and everything to do with the anti-democratic tendencies in today’s global capitalism). If we understand cynicism as ruthless pragmatism of power which secretly laughs at its own principles, then Pussy Riot are anti-cynicism embodied. Their message is: IDEAS MATTER. They are conceptual artists in the noblest sense of the word: artists who embody an Idea. This is why they wear balaclavas: masks of de-individualization, of liberating anonymity. The message of their balaclavas is that it doesn’t matter which of them got arrested — they’re not individuals, they’re an Idea. And this is why they are such a threat: it is easy to imprison individuals, but try to imprison an Idea!

The panic of those in power — displayed by their ridiculously excessive brutal reaction — is thus fully justified. The more brutally they act, the more important symbol Pussy Riot will become. Already now the result of the oppressive measures is that Pussy Riot are a household name literally all around the world.

It is the sacred duty of all of us to prevent that the courageous individuals who compose Pussy Riot will not pay in their flesh the price for their becoming a global symbol.

Slavoj Žižek

29 Comments

Filed under feminism, gay rights, international affairs, open letters, manifestos, appeals, political repression, Russian society

29 responses to ““The True Blasphemy”: Slavoj Žižek on Pussy Riot

  1. barrie

    “masks of de-individualization, of liberating anonymity. The message of their balaclavas is that it doesn’t matter which of them got arrested — they’re not individuals, they’re an Idea. And this is wh
    y they are such a threat: it is easy to imprison individuals, but try to imprison an Idea!” THIS IS TRUE OF THE GUERRILLA GIRLS TOO, GOING BACK TO THE 1980s.

  2. Pingback: Pussy Riot, Madonna, High Court Hijinks and What it means to be a Hooligan | Baibakov Art Projects

  3. Pingback:   “La vera bestemmia”: Slavoj Žižek sulle Pussy Riot — Sandwiches di realtà. il blog di Maurizio Acerbo

  4. Pingback: Η πραγματική βλασφημία του Σλάβοϊ Ζίζεκ

  5. Pingback: Η πραγματική βλασφημία – Του Σλάβοϊ Ζίζεκ

  6. Pingback: “The True Blasphemy”: Slavoj Žižek on Pussy Riot | Aristonico Belargio

  7. Pingback: Pussy Riot: Slavoj Žižek @ Máquina Sociológica

  8. Pingback: Pussy Riot: Slavoj Žižek « Máquina Semiótica

  9. Pingback: Russia: “The True Blasphemy” – Slavoj Žižek on Pussy Riot · Global Voices

  10. Pingback: Русија: „Вистинското богохулие“ – Славој Жижек за Пуси рајот · Global Voices на македонски

  11. Zizek is just a hooligan with a reverence for Christian night soil.

  12. Pingback: Official Russia | Russia: “The True Blasphemy” – Slavoj Žižek on Pussy Riot

  13. “IDEAS MATTER.” I really really want to believe this, but, to be honest, I am not sure what the ideas are in this case. “You keep your church out of my pussy and I’ll keep my pussy riot out of your church.” There is an idea there of the separation of church and something (not sure what exactly: the bedroom, public displays of sexuality, gynecology, anything that can be called a female issue – not sure) but the idea is completely overshadowed by the image. IMAGES MATTER is unfortunately the overriding message. Others (I seem to remember an ex-chessplayer) have been insisting on principles in Russian political life, but because they were rather grey and boring they never got much global media attention.

    In today’s media circus I am not sure how anyone could consistently and successfully promote the idea that ideas matter. Zizek does a good job, but I still suspect that people come as much for the laughs as for the ideas.

  14. Pingback: Настоящее кощунство: Славой Жижек о Pussy Riot | Industrial Silence

  15. Pingback: Настоящее кощунство: Славой Жижек о Pussy Riot

  16. Francesco

    Slavoj, I don’t agree at all with your opinion on the Pussy Riot affair. This is my contribution:

    http://www.facebook.com/notes/francesco-macheda/the-great-pussy-riot-swindle/10151020558172887

  17. Lutz

    Folks check the last sentence! I don’t think the “not” is supposed to be in there.

  18. Pingback: Pussy Riot, colpevoli e vincitrici « femminileplurale

  19. Pingback: GPJA #439 (Part 2): International news & Analysis – 22/8/12 « GPJA's Blog

  20. Pingback: Nrmal.net — En tiempos de cambio

  21. Pingback: Free Pussy Riot – Jetzt erst recht! (2) « shifting reality

  22. Pingback: What is Pussy Riot’s ‘idea’? | Sithamu

  23. Pingback: What is Pussy Riot’s ‘Idea’? — Incunabula: Ong's Hat

  24. Pingback: Get Latest News Around The World

  25. Pingback: Pussy Riot freigesprochen. | Sekt und Brezel

  26. Pingback: Non ha più senso dire borghesia. Analisi di due esempi di costruttivismo linguistico: l’uso del termine “borghese” e il caso Pussy Riot | Critica Impura

  27. Pingback: The importance of Pussy Riot – an article (2012) | The Real Life of An American Indian

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s